Surface appearances lead many shoppers to believe that tungsten rings and titanium are the same. However, the two metals are quite different. Before you decide which to get, here’s a quick guide to help you know what is better, tungsten or titanium.
1. Durability
Between the two, tungsten is stronger and more durable. On the Mohs scale, tungsten ranks as the harder metal at 8.5 to 9, while titanium ranks further down at 6. This means that there is virtually nothing, apart from diamonds, that can scratch tungsten, which further means that it may remain free of scuffs and marks. However, this does not mean that a tungsten ring is indestructible as it is extremely brittle and can break when you drop it.
Titanium, on the other hand, is harder than gold and platinum. Unlike tungsten, it is not prone to breaking. Under high pressure, titanium will bend and deform while tungsten will shatter.
2. Weight
In terms of weight, titanium rings are a lot more lightweight than tungsten rings. It is often called “weightless” or “featherweight.” On the other hand, tungsten rings will feel denser and heavier, which is suitable for people who prefer that weighty feel on their fingers.
3. Color
Both tungsten rings and titanium rings have a classic silver colour. However, titanium can be anodized to produce other colours, allowing for more choices. Tungsten can also be plated to acquire other colours.
4. Composition
Tungsten carbide is a compound made from tungsten and an equal number of carbon atoms. On the other hand, tungsten, when used in jewellery, is slightly alloyed with other elements like aluminum and vanadium. For titanium jewellery, the most commonly used grade is at least 85% pure titanium.
5. Hypoallergenic Properties
Many couples often look for hypoallergenic rings, and most titanium rings come with hypoallergenic properties, which is perfect for people with skin allergies. However, many tungsten carbide rings are not hypoallergenic due to their cobalt content.
6. Engraving
Wedding rings are usually customised to reflect a personalised message inside, and both tungsten rings and titanium rings can be made into custom engraved rings. Titanium, due to its softness, can be engraved by traditional methods, which involves carving the message directly into the ring.
On the other hand, because it is a lot harder, tungsten requires alternative methods, such as laser engraving. Many people prefer laser engraving because it is smoother to the touch.
7. Resizing
In general, both titanium rings and tungsten rings cannot be resized. If your ring does not fit you anymore, then you will have to buy a new one.
8. Safety
A common myth regarding tungsten and titanium rings is that they are impossible to remove in case of emergency, but this is not true. Both rings can certainly be removed, although the method for removal varies. Titanium rings need to be cut using tools like a jeweler’s saw, while tungsten rings need to be cracked using vice grip pliers.
9. Price
Both tungsten rings and titanium rings are affordable alternatives to pricier precious metals. The prices may vary from $10 to $1000, which depends on the jewellery’s quality, design, and craftsmanship. In general, though, titanium is less expensive than tungsten.
10. Availability
Because of their popularity, it is quite easy to find both tungsten rings and titanium rings. They are available in many physical jewellery stores, and a lot of choices can also be found online.
What is better, tungsten or titanium? Both tungsten rings and titanium rings have their own advantages and disadvantages. Choose one that best suits your preferences and lifestyle.